When it comes to roofing, many homeowners focus solely on shingles, overlooking the crucial materials beneath them. The layer directly under shingles plays a key role in ensuring the longevity and efficiency of your roof. This protective barrier, known as roof underlayment, serves as the first line of defense against water, wind, and harsh weather conditions. In this article, we will explore the types of underlayment materials, their benefits, and why they matter to the overall health of your roof.

Roof underlayment installation under shingles

The Importance of Roof Underlayment 

Roof underlayment, also referred to as a “roofing protection layer,” is a material installed between the roof deck and the shingles. Its primary purpose is to act as an additional shield to protect your home from water penetration, leaks, and environmental damage. Roofs face constant exposure to the elements, including rain, snow, and even intense UV rays. The underlayment ensures that even if shingles are damaged or removed, water and debris are kept from entering your home.

Not all underlayments are created equal. The type of roofing material choices you make for this layer can significantly affect the overall performance and durability of your roof. Let’s dive deeper into the types of underlayment and how they compare.

Types of Roofing Underlayment

Felt Paper (Asphalt-Saturated Felt) 

Felt underlayment is one of the traditional choices and has been used for decades by roofers. Made from a mix of asphalt and natural materials, it is known for its flexibility and affordability. Available in two primary thicknesses, 15-pound and 30-pound, felt underlayment offers moderate protection against water infiltration. The thicker 30-pound version is more durable and suitable for areas with harsher climates.

However, felt has its limitations. While it provides a good moisture barrier, it can become brittle in extreme heat or crack over time in cold conditions. Additionally, it’s heavier than newer materials, which can be a factor in roofing systems with weight restrictions.

Synthetic Underlayment 

A more modern alternative is synthetic underlayment, often favored by roofing contractors for its enhanced durability and lightweight design. Made from polyethylene or polypropylene, synthetic underlayment is resistant to tearing, UV rays, and mold growth. Its flexibility allows roofers to easily install it over irregular surfaces, ensuring maximum coverage.

Synthetic underlayment is highly water-resistant, making it an excellent option for areas prone to heavy rainfall or high humidity. Another advantage is its longer lifespan compared to felt, with many synthetic products designed to last the lifetime of the roof. Given its superior performance and ease of installation, it has become the preferred choice for professional roofers across the industry.

Rubberized Asphalt Underlayment

Rubberized asphalt underlayment is a premium option, often used in areas of the roof that are most vulnerable to leaks, such as valleys and eaves. It has a self-adhesive backing that creates a watertight seal when applied, offering superior protection from moisture infiltration. Due to its high resistance to both temperature fluctuations and extreme weather, this type of underlayment is ideal for climates with heavy snow, ice, or intense storms.

Though more expensive than felt or synthetic options, rubberized asphalt provides long-lasting protection, particularly in critical areas of the roof. Many roofing contractors recommend using it in combination with other underlayments to enhance the overall effectiveness of the roofing system.

Roof underlayment installation, showing its protective layer

Why Roof Underlayment Matters 

Choosing the right underlayment is essential for maintaining the structural integrity of your roof. Without it, even the best shingles would be vulnerable to leaks, mold growth, and rotting. Here are some key reasons why underlayment matters:

Protection from Moisture 

One of the main functions of underlayment is to provide a waterproof barrier beneath the shingles. It catches any water that seeps through damaged or displaced shingles, preventing it from reaching the roof deck and causing rot or mold. Even in areas without heavy rainfall, condensation can form beneath shingles, making moisture protection a critical aspect of your roofing system.

Temperature Regulation 

Underlayment also acts as an insulating layer, helping to regulate temperatures within your home. It reduces heat transfer from the outside, keeping your home cooler in the summer and warmer in the winter. Proper insulation is essential for energy efficiency and can significantly lower heating and cooling costs.

Wind and Storm Resistance 

In regions prone to high winds and storms, underlayment adds an extra layer of security against wind-driven rain. Strong winds can lift shingles, creating opportunities for water to infiltrate the roof. Underlayment helps prevent wind from penetrating your roofing system and provides additional reinforcement in case shingles are blown off during severe weather.

Roof underlayment installation mistakes showing misaligned sheets, gaps, and curling edges

Common Mistakes in Installing Roofing Underlayment 

Even the best underlayment won’t perform well if not installed properly. Here are some common mistakes that roofing contractors must avoid:

Improper Overlapping

When installing underlayment, each sheet must overlap the previous one to ensure complete coverage. Failure to overlap properly can result in water seeping through the gaps, rendering the underlayment ineffective. Following the manufacturer’s guidelines for overlap is crucial to preventing leaks.

Inadequate Fastening 

Roofing nails or staples should be used to securely fasten the underlayment to the roof deck. If the fasteners are spaced too far apart or aren’t applied consistently, the underlayment could shift or tear over time, especially in high-wind areas.

Ignoring Climate Considerations 

Choosing the wrong type of underlayment for your region’s climate can result in premature roof failure. For example, using felt in a high-humidity area can lead to moisture problems, while synthetic underlayment may be overkill for dry, temperate climates. It’s essential to consult with a professional roofing contractor to select the best underlayment for your specific weather conditions.

Roof underlayment being installed on a house with wooden deck

Choosing the Right Underlayment for Your Roof 

Choosing the correct underlayment is a pivotal decision that impacts the performance and longevity of your roof. Several factors, such as local climate, roofing material, and financial considerations, come into play when making this choice. Understanding these variables ensures you make an informed decision that enhances your roof’s protection and lifespan.

Felt Paper: Budget-Friendly and Functional 

For homeowners working with a constrained budget, felt paper can be a viable option. It’s most effective in regions with moderate weather, where temperature fluctuations and precipitation remain manageable. Although it lacks the advanced features of modern alternatives, felt paper offers reliable performance in low-risk environments. Its affordability makes it an attractive solution for basic roofing projects, but it may not withstand more extreme weather conditions.

Synthetic Underlayment: Built for Durability and Moisture Resistance 

In areas with high humidity or frequent rainfall, synthetic underlayment rises as the preferred choice. Engineered for durability, it offers superior resistance to moisture infiltration, making it ideal for regions prone to heavy precipitation. Unlike traditional materials, synthetic underlayment resists tears and is lighter, simplifying installation without compromising strength. This long-lasting option not only protects your roof from the elements but also provides excellent value for its longevity.

Rubberized Asphalt: Unyielding in Extreme Conditions 

When dealing with harsh environments, where snow accumulation and ice are commonplace, rubberized asphalt underlayment provides unmatched protection. Its specialized composition allows it to create an impermeable barrier, especially in areas vulnerable to leaks or water damage. If your region faces freezing temperatures, extreme weather conditions, or frequent storms, this type of underlayment is indispensable. Its flexibility and adhesive qualities make it an excellent choice for sealing off critical areas like valleys, ridges, and eaves, where leaks are most likely to occur.

Adherence to Local Building Codes 

Regardless of which underlayment you select, it’s crucial that the material adheres to local building codes and regulations. Certain regions, especially those prone to wildfires or hurricanes, may have stringent requirements for roof underlayment. For instance, fire-resistant underlayment might be mandated in wildfire zones, while wind-resistant materials are often required in hurricane-prone areas. Always ensure your selection not only suits your roof’s needs but also complies with regional mandates to avoid costly future adjustments or legal complications.

Conclusion

Roof underlayment is a critical component of any roofing system, offering protection from moisture, insulation, and enhanced durability. Understanding your roofing material choices and selecting the right underlayment can extend the life of your roof and improve the overall performance of your home. Whether you opt for felt, synthetic, or rubberized asphalt, always ensure your roofing system is installed by a qualified professional to maximize its effectiveness.

For any roofing projects or advice on underlayment, don’t hesitate to consult an experienced roofing contractor. They can guide you through the selection process and ensure your roof is equipped to handle whatever nature throws at it.

FAQs about Roof Underlayment

  • Why Is Roofing Underlayment Necessary?
    Roofing underlayment acts as a secondary moisture barrier, protecting your home from leaks in case shingles are damaged or displaced. It also helps with insulation and wind resistance.

  • How Long Does Underlayment Last?
    The lifespan of roof underlayment depends on the material. Felt paper typically lasts 15-20 years, while synthetic and rubberized asphalt underlayment can last up to 50 years or more, depending on installation and maintenance.

  • Can Underlayment Alone Protect the Roof?
    No, underlayment is designed to work in conjunction with shingles or other roofing materials. It is not a standalone protective layer but enhances the overall durability and moisture resistance of the roof.

  • Can I Install Underlayment Myself?
    While it’s possible to install underlayment yourself, it’s always best to hire a professional roofing contractor. Proper installation is key to ensuring the material provides maximum protection and longevity.

  • Is Synthetic Underlayment Better Than Felt?
    Synthetic underlayment offers superior durability, moisture resistance, and UV protection compared to felt. However, it is more expensive, so the best choice depends on your budget and climate.