At Shumaker Roofing, we stand firmly by our belief—CertainTeed Shingles are unparalleled in the industry. While some may dismiss this as mere opinion, any seasoned roofing contractor will affirm that CertainTeed shingles are celebrated for their exceptional quality, unmatched durability, and remarkable affordability.

Curious about what makes CertainTeed shingles good? Allow us to delve into the details, equipping you with the knowledge you need to make an informed decision when it’s time to replace your roof.

Asphalt shingle roof on a residential roof

About CertainTeed Shingles

For over a century, CertainTeed has dominated the roofing industry with unparalleled products and innovative shingles. Established in 1904 as the “General Roofing Manufacturing Company,” the brand redefined itself in 1917, adopting the name “CertainTeed” from its bold commitment to quality—”Quality made certain, Satisfaction Guaranteed.”

By 1917, CertainTeed had ascended to become North America’s foremost asphalt shingle producer, carving out a reputation that remains unrivaled. Today, CertainTeed employs a dedicated workforce of 6,300, each contributing to its legacy. The Landmark series stands as a testament to this excellence, recognized nationwide as a symbol of quality and dependability by roofing contractors across the United States.

A house with a freshly installed CertainTeed shingle roof, showcasing its high-quality texture and aesthetic appeal

Advantages: Why CertainTeed Shingles Are Preferred by Contractors and Homeowners 

When it comes to selecting shingles for a roof replacement, CertainTeed shingles consistently rank at the top, competing with industry giants like GAF and Owens Corning. While your choice might be influenced by the contractor you hire, the focus should always be on selecting the best shingle for your home, not just what a contractor has on hand. Here are the key reasons why leading roofing contractors consistently choose CertainTeed shingles:

Enhanced Durability with Thicker Layers 

CertainTeed’s Landmark shingles are renowned for their exceptional thickness, setting them apart in the roofing industry. As a heavyweight brand, Landmark shingles provide a tangible sense of quality and durability. To fully appreciate the difference, compare a bundle of GAF shingles with a bundle of CertainTeed Landmark shingles—you’ll notice the substantial weight difference, with CertainTeed shingles weighing in at approximately 300 pounds per 100 square feet. This extra heft translates to greater durability and a longer lifespan, making them an excellent choice for homeowners seeking lasting protection.

Competitive Pricing with Superior Value 

The adage “you get what you pay for” holds true with CertainTeed shingles. Priced competitively with other top brands, CertainTeed Landmark shingles often offer even greater value, particularly when considering their superior warranty and material quality. While the initial cost may be slightly higher in some cases, the long-term savings derived from the durability and extended warranty coverage more than justify the investment.

Premium Aesthetic Appeal 

CertainTeed’s Landmark shingles are not just functional; they also excel in design. With a broad array of colors and dimensional options, including luxury shingles, these shingles enhance the aesthetic appeal of any home. The expertly blended colors emulate the rich, textured look of traditional “Shake” shingles, but with the added resilience of asphalt. This unique combination of beauty and strength makes CertainTeed shingles a top choice for those looking to boost their home’s curb appeal.

Extensive Color Selection

The Landmark series by CertainTeed offers an extensive palette of colors, providing homeowners with the flexibility to customize their home’s exterior to match their personal style. This diverse range of hues not only enhances the visual appeal of the home but also contributes to higher resale values. A well-chosen shingle color can make a significant impact on the overall look and feel of a property, making CertainTeed’s color options a valuable asset for any homeowner.

Unparalleled Warranty Protection 

CertainTeed shingles come with some of the best warranty options in the industry, including coverage for winds up to 130 MPH and protection against streaking. This robust warranty ensures that homeowners are safeguarded against a wide range of potential issues, providing peace of mind that their investment is protected. The comprehensive nature of CertainTeed’s warranty is a testament to the confidence they have in their product’s quality and durability.

Rigorous Installer Selection 

To further ensure quality, CertainTeed has established a Master Shingle Installer program that rigorously vets roofing contractors who use their products. This selective process protects homeowners by ensuring that only skilled, certified professionals install their shingles. By choosing a contractor who is part of this program, homeowners can be confident that their installation will be performed to the highest standards, safeguarding both the roof’s longevity and the warranty coverage.

Weathered shingles on an older roof, showing cracks, curling, and missing granules, with a contractor examining the damage

Challenges Associated with CertainTeed Shingles

The Sole Drawback: Cost 

The primary critique directed toward CertainTeed shingles revolves around their cost. While the price point is indeed higher compared to other brands, this is often the only significant negative aspect highlighted by critics. However, this perspective overlooks the broader context of quality and long-term value. The initial investment may be steeper, but what you receive in return is a product that stands the test of time.

Misleading Comparisons by Competitors 

It’s crucial to recognize that any contractor who claims that alternative shingle brands outperform CertainTeed is likely not providing a fair assessment. The performance, aesthetic appeal, and resilience of CertainTeed shingles are unparalleled in the industry. Such claims may stem from personal preferences or financial incentives rather than an objective evaluation of product quality. The marginal savings offered by cheaper brands often come at the cost of longevity and overall satisfaction.

The Weight and Cost Trade-Off 

CertainTeed shingles are known for their robust construction, which makes them slightly heavier than some competitors. This difference in weight is sometimes cited by contractors as a reason to opt for lighter, more economical alternatives. However, this argument fails to account for the added durability and protection that comes with a more substantial shingle. In the long run, homeowners may find that the minor inconvenience of heavier shingles is far outweighed by the benefits of enhanced durability and weather resistance.

Warranty Considerations 

Another point of contention is the extended warranty cost associated with CertainTeed shingles. Some may argue that the requirement to use exclusively CertainTeed products throughout the entire roofing system inflates the warranty price. However, this practice is not unique to CertainTeed; it is a common industry standard. The logic behind this requirement is sound: a cohesive system designed by a single manufacturer ensures optimal performance and compatibility, ultimately providing greater peace of mind to the homeowner.

The Bottom Line

In summary, the perceived drawbacks of CertainTeed shingles are often overstated or based on a narrow view of initial costs. When evaluating roofing materials, it’s important to consider the broader picture—longevity, performance, and overall value. CertainTeed shingles may come with a higher price tag, but they also deliver superior quality and protection, making them a wise investment for those who prioritize long-term reliability and aesthetic appeal.

View of different CertainTeed shingle roof types

Types of CertainTeed Shingles

3-Tab Shingles: XT 25 

For those seeking a straightforward, dependable roofing solution, XT 25 3-tab shingles stand as a solid choice. These shingles are often favored by contractors for their simplicity and reliability. Built to withstand the elements, they offer a fundamental level of protection at a competitive price point. The XT 25 is ideal for homeowners who prioritize functionality without the frills, ensuring a roof that performs consistently over time. With their traditional design, these shingles provide an enduring aesthetic, suitable for a variety of home styles.

Landmark PRO & Premium Architectural Asphalt Shingles 

Elevated Durability with Striking Aesthetics 

Landmark PRO & Premium architectural asphalt shingles offer a blend of robustness and visual allure. These dimensional shingles, designed with two laminated layers, mimic the textured look of authentic wood shake. This layered design not only adds depth but also enhances curb appeal, making them a favored choice among discerning homeowners. The Max Def colors further accentuate the roof’s appearance, providing a vivid and long-lasting finish that elevates the overall look of any home.

Cost-Effective Enhancement 

Architectural shingles stand out not just for their resilience but also for their cost-effectiveness. Upgrading from basic contractor-grade strip shingles to these high-performance dimensional shingles often involves a minimal additional investment. This upgrade yields significant returns in terms of longevity and aesthetic appeal, making it a prudent choice for homeowners seeking both durability and style.

Luxury Asphalt Shingles 

CertainTeed provides an array of luxury asphalt shingles, each meticulously crafted to enhance curb appeal and withstand the elements. These premium shingle options, while commanding a higher investment, offer unparalleled durability and aesthetic sophistication. The collection includes the following distinguished styles:

Carriage House Style

The Carriage House style exudes timeless elegance, reminiscent of the stately roofs that adorned grand estates of the past. Its unique scalloped design and rich, dimensional profile create a visually striking effect, setting it apart from standard shingles. The robust construction ensures longevity, making it a wise choice for those seeking both style and substance.

Grand Manor Style

Grand Manor shingles embody architectural grandeur, delivering the look of natural slate with the added benefit of modern performance. These shingles feature deep shadow lines and intricate detail, replicating the texture and depth of authentic slate. Ideal for homes with steeply pitched roofs, Grand Manor shingles enhance the structural magnificence of any property.

Presidential Shake IR and TL

Presidential Shake IR and TL shingles offer the rustic charm of hand-split cedar shakes with the resilience of impact-resistant technology. These shingles are engineered to endure harsh weather conditions, including hail and strong winds, without compromising on aesthetic appeal. The Presidential Shake line is the pinnacle of luxury, combining heritage-inspired design with state-of-the-art protection.

Landmark IR 

Landmark IR shingles are designed for homeowners who demand superior protection and refined style. With impact resistance at the forefront, these shingles offer a classic architectural look that complements a wide range of home styles. Their layered construction not only enhances curb appeal but also provides added security against the unpredictable forces of nature.

Landmark TL

The Landmark TL series offers a sophisticated twist on traditional asphalt shingles, with triple-layer construction that provides extraordinary thickness and dimension. These shingles are crafted to mimic the appearance of wood shake, adding character and charm to any roof. Their enhanced durability ensures a long-lasting roof that maintains its beauty over time.

Presidential Solaris

Presidential Solaris shingles represent the intersection of luxury and energy efficiency. These innovative shingles reflect solar energy, reducing roof temperature and lowering cooling costs. The Presidential Solaris line offers the distinguished look of wood shake with the added benefit of environmental sustainability, making it an excellent choice for eco-conscious homeowners.

Presidential Shake 

Presidential Shake shingles are designed to replicate the look of authentic wood shakes, offering deep dimension and a rugged, natural appearance. These shingles are the top choice for those who appreciate the rustic beauty of wood but desire the durability and low maintenance of asphalt. The Presidential Shake series stands out for its rich color palette and distinctive texture, making it a premium option for discerning homeowners.

Symphony 

The Symphony series captures the essence of natural slate, offering a sophisticated roofing solution with the benefits of modern engineering. These shingles are lightweight, easy to install, and resistant to the elements, all while delivering the classic beauty of slate. The Symphony collection is perfect for homeowners seeking an elegant, high-performance roof that echoes the timeless appeal of slate without the associated weight and cost.

Roofing contractor installing CertainTeed shingles on a residential roof in a suburban neighborhood

CertainTeed Shingles: Pricing and Installation Breakdown 

Cost of CertainTeed Shingles

CertainTeed shingles offer a range of options, each catering to different preferences and budgets. Here’s a closer look at their pricing:

  • Landmark Three-Tab: $80 per square. This economical choice provides reliable protection and a classic appearance.

  • Landmark Premium: $120 per square. These shingles combine durability with enhanced aesthetics, offering a balanced option for homeowners.

  • Landmark Pro: $150 per square. Designed for longevity and superior performance, these shingles are a top pick for those seeking value and quality.

  • Luxury Shingles: $175+ per square. The pinnacle of roofing materials, these shingles provide unmatched beauty and protection, ideal for premium homes.

Understanding Installation Costs 

Installation significantly impacts the total cost of a roof replacement. Roofing companies typically purchase shingles ahead of time to ensure they are ready for installation. The process of replacing a roof is more than just laying down shingles. It involves several critical steps:

  • Tearing Off Old Shingles: The existing shingles are removed to expose the roof deck.

  • Installing Underlayment: A protective layer is added to guard against moisture.

  • Applying Drip Edge: This component prevents water from seeping under the edges of the roof.

  • Laying Down New Shingles: The chosen shingles are meticulously placed to ensure maximum durability.

  • Adding Flashing and Ridge Vents: Flashing seals joints and edges, while ridge vents allow for proper attic ventilation.

These elements contribute to the overall cost, with installation prices ranging from $400 to $700 per square, depending on the complexity of the job and the materials used.

Calculating Your Roof Replacement Cost 

One roofing square covers 100 square feet. To estimate the total cost of your roof replacement, consider the number of squares needed and the installation cost per square. For example, if your roof requires 20 squares (2,000 square feet) and the cost per square installed is $500, your total roof replacement would be $10,000. This aligns closely with the national average, ensuring you receive both value and quality in your roofing investment.

Hands holding warranty documents with extended warranty booklet on a desk

Warranty Claim and Extended Warranty Information

CertainTeed Warranty Highlights 

Lifetime Limited Transferable Warranty – Residential: 

CertainTeed offers a robust lifetime limited warranty that’s transferable to new homeowners. This warranty is a testament to the durability and long-term protection of their products, providing homeowners with peace of mind for the lifetime of the roof.

50-Year Limited Transferable Warranty – Group-Owned or Commercial: 

For group-owned or commercial properties, CertainTeed extends a 50-year limited transferable warranty. This warranty ensures that even large-scale properties receive the same rigorous protection, reflecting the confidence in the material’s longevity and performance over time.

15-Year StreakFighter® Warranty: 

The 15-year StreakFighter® warranty is designed to combat algae staining, ensuring that the aesthetic appeal of your roof remains uncompromised. This specialized warranty highlights CertainTeed’s commitment to maintaining the visual integrity of your roof by using advanced materials that resist unsightly streaks.

10-Year SureStart™ Protection:

During the critical first 10 years, the SureStart™ protection plan covers both labor and materials. This guarantee showcases CertainTeed’s dedication to standing behind their products, ensuring that any defects or issues that arise in this

Importance of Wind Resistance in Asphalt Shingles 

Understanding the significance of wind resistance in your asphalt shingles is crucial for safeguarding your home. Asphalt shingles rated for 130 mph winds provide essential protection against powerful gusts, especially during severe weather events like hurricanes. Ensuring that your shingles meet this standard means you can face the fury of a Category 3 hurricane with confidence, knowing your home is fortified against winds that could reach up to 130 mph.

Hurricane Wind Speeds and Their Impact

Hurricanes are classified by wind speed, with each category posing greater danger. A Category 1 hurricane, with winds of 74-95 mph, can cause significant roof damage. As the wind increases, so does the risk to your home.

Category 2 hurricanes, with 96-110 mph winds, can uproot trees, rip off roofing, and cause serious structural damage. These winds are a major threat to your home’s integrity.

Category 3 hurricanes, with 111-129 mph winds, are considered major hurricanes. They can cause devastating damage, especially to homes with weak roofs. It’s crucial to have shingles that can withstand these powerful forces.

The Necessity of 130 mph Wind Coverage

Protecting your home from the extreme conditions of a hurricane begins with your roof. Shingles rated for 130 mph winds offer a level of security that is not just recommended but necessary in hurricane-prone areas. This coverage ensures that your roof can resist the powerful gusts of a Category 3 hurricane, significantly reducing the risk of shingle loss and subsequent damage to the interior of your home.

Conclusion

When it comes to roofing shingles, we prioritize excellence and endurance for our homeowners. Quality and durability aren’t just important—they’re essential. Opting for subpar materials might save a few dollars initially, but the long-term consequences could be costly and troublesome.

Think about the purpose of an asphalt shingle. It’s the first line of defense against nature’s harshest elements, tirelessly safeguarding your home through every season. This task requires resilience. CertainTeed shingles are revered among roofing experts for their superior quality and performance. They’re not just a brand choice; they’re a commitment to reliability and protection.

FAQs

  • How long do CertainTeed shingles typically last?
    CertainTeed shingles are known for their durability, with the Landmark series often lasting 30 years or more when properly installed and maintained. Their longevity can be attributed to their superior construction and high-quality materials.

  • Are CertainTeed shingles energy-efficient?
    Yes, CertainTeed offers energy-efficient shingle options that can help reduce your home’s energy consumption. Products like the Landmark Solaris series are designed to reflect more sunlight and reduce heat absorption, leading to potential energy savings.

  • Do CertainTeed shingles come with a warranty?
    Absolutely. CertainTeed provides a comprehensive warranty for their shingles, which can vary depending on the product line and specific warranty package chosen. Many of their shingles come with a limited lifetime warranty, providing peace of mind for homeowners.

  • Can CertainTeed shingles be used in all climates?
    CertainTeed shingles are designed to perform well in a variety of climates. Whether you live in a region with extreme heat, cold, or heavy precipitation, CertainTeed has shingles specifically engineered to withstand different weather conditions.

  • How do CertainTeed shingles compare to other brands?
    CertainTeed shingles are highly regarded for their quality and performance, often competing favorably with other top brands like GAF and Owens Corning. The choice between brands will depend on specific needs and preferences, but CertainTeed consistently stands out for its durability, warranty, and innovative features.